For What It's Worth

For What It's Worth

Monday, November 16, 2015

Mini reviews…First & Then by Emma Mills, A Step Towards Falling by Cammie McGovern

Both First & Then and A Step towards Falling have a Pride & Prejudice, football theme.

Both do a great job at exploring the difficult time of transitioning from adolescence to adulthood. They both also explore difficult topics with a lighter touch – which didn’t quite work for me. They seemed more intent on squeezing their romance into the Pride and Prejudice Elizabeth/Darcy mold rather than addressing some of the weightier issues they brought up.

But here are my quick thoughts and you decide for yourself if they might work better for you…


23310751Devon Tennyson wouldn't change a thing. She's happy watching Friday night games from the bleachers, silently crushing on best friend Cas, and blissfully ignoring the future after high school. But the universe has other plans. It delivers Devon's cousin Foster, an unrepentant social outlier with a surprising talent for football, and the obnoxiously superior and maddeningly attractive star running back, Ezra, right where she doesn't want them first into her P.E. class and then into every other aspect of her life.

Pride and Prejudice meets Friday Night Lights in this contemporary novel about falling in love with the unexpected boy, with a new brother, and with yourself. ~
Goodreads


Source: ARC provided by publisher via BEA15

My thoughts: First & Then was a book I devoured in three hours. It was a light, fluffy read that brought back a lot of those awkward teenage feelings from high school. Devon is average – no great skills, or interests (other than reading and comparing her life to P&P) and that’s something I could really relate to. She’s juggling an unrequited crush on her best friend, a cousin who she feels protective over, even though he puts her firmly in the uncool camp because of his childlike enthusiasm, and decisions about her future.

There’s no big dramatic story arc and the side characters are never developed enough for you to feel overly invested in the outcome despite the heavier topics it skirts around- and Foster pretty much steals the show - but I liked First & Then despite the flaws.


***  



27072945In A Step Toward Falling, Cammie McGovern tells a poignant, compelling story of not judging people on appearances and knowing how to fix the things you've broken.

Emily has always been the kind of girl who tries to do the right thing - until one night when she does the worst thing possible. She sees Belinda, a classmate with developmental disabilities, being attacked. Inexplicably, she does nothing at all.

Belinda, however, manages to save herself. When their high school finds out what happened, Emily and Lucas, a football player who was also there that night, are required to perform community service at a center for disabled people. Soon, Lucas and Emily begin to feel like maybe they're starting to make a real difference. Like they would be able to do the right thing if they could do that night all over again. But can they do anything that will actually help the one person they hurt the most? ~ Goodreads


Source: ARC provided by the publisher via BEA15

My thoughts: This was another good book that explored the responsibilities and decisions that mark the transition into adulthood. I also love how McGovern writes people with disabilities as fully fleshed out characters with hopes, dreams and sexuality. (As she also did in her debut novel, Say What You Will). If A Step Towards Falling was just about that it would have worked better for me.

Emily and Lucas are assigned to community service at a center for people with disabilities after witnessing and attack on a girl with developmental disabilities that they did nothing to stop. The story is told from both Emily (one of the witnesses) and Belinda (the girl who was attacked).

As much as I may have liked the individual storylines - like the romance, the volunteering - I had a problem with turning something as serious as rape, into a lighter story so that the leads could find romance! and put on a play! It’s not that any of that is wrong or even unrealistic but it was so weird to just gloss over something like that and then think a rousing rendition of Pride and Prejudice will be just the thing to put things right.

19 comments:

  1. A Pride & Prejudice, football theme? I am intrigued.

    Funny how so many of us enjoy 'high school reads' despite the fact they bring back so many memories of what after all is often one of the most awkward, possibly painful, times in our lives.

    Great reviews, thank you.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I hated high school! lol

      It is interesting to read about from my older self perspective. I do wish I had these books when I was younger. They would have really helped me realize that this is a universal experience - I wasn't alone.

      Delete
  2. I dont think I like how raped was handled in that book after reading so many reviews by others of it.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. It wasn't exactly ignored but....it felt like more of a catalyst for two other characters development and romance and that felt wrong.

      Delete
  3. Hi Karen, hope you're doing well!! I've read a few reviews on In A Step Toward Falling and liked the way Belinda's character sounds, yet I've heard many mention that the rape is not handled with as much finesse as the rest of the book, which is too bad.

    I'm glad you enjoyed First & Then though, it sounds really wonderful! :)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Belinda was awesome and I like dhow she was written. I had a problem with worrying more about the other two characters romantic prospects over something like rape. It bothered me.

      Delete
  4. Rape, then light and romance and a play...eh

    ReplyDelete
  5. I've been wanting to read First and Then. So pushing it up the wishlist. I think I'd have the same problem as you did with Step. I don't like that such a serious topic was glossed over.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. First & Then is cute but maybe a victim of overhype for me. I expected this incredibly emotional book and ....meh

      Delete
  6. I tried to read First and Then, but had trouble getting into it. I may try again. And we agreed on Step. I thought a book about preconceptions, misconceptions etc is a great idea, but it also bothered me that the attempted rape was just brushed off.

    ReplyDelete
  7. What ninny would give a go signal to "light" rape???

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. It wasn't that so much that as letting the people who could have helped off the hook by focusing on their romance more what they did (or didn't do) and Belinda's issues after.

      Delete
  8. I've heard mixed things about First and Then, but I'm not terribly interested. A Step Towards Falling sounds like it could have been really, really good...but that's a bummer they gloss over a really serious topic too much to have lighter moments and romance.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. First & Then is cute enough - just didn't stand out as much as I thought it would.

      I had a hard time with how the rape/victim issue was dealt with in A Step Towards Falling. Some of it was well done - but overall it felt kind of flippant.

      Delete
  9. I agree it was a little glossed over, but overall I liked both of these as well

    ReplyDelete